📄 Contents
This resource has been kindly put together by Karl Bentley from RSM.
There’s always a lot of discussion in the FE and Skills sector about how ESFA assurance reviews operate. Some of this is correct and some of this is misinformed As someone who has worked in this area for nearly 20 years I thought I’d give an overview of the process and try to dispel some myths and set the record straight on how the ESFA assurance approach works.
The main reason usually is it’s your time. The ESFA has to complete a required amount of assurance coverage on the sector to demonstrate to the National Audit Office (NAO) that the funding they are responsible for is being spent on the purposes it was intended for. All providers in receipt of ESFA funding are in scope and a sample of these are selected each year. This is referred to as the ‘random’ sample. A provider can also be selected as part of a risk review. Providers in this category have been selected as the ESFA has concerns in relation to data quality or issues have been identified from previous funding assurance related activity.
It is possible that a provider picked in a random sample one year may be reviewed again in the following year as a risk provider if the results of the assurance review identified significant issues which resulted in recovery of funds.
A common question is often ‘we haven’t been audited for years and I know we’re due. Do you think we’ll get picked up in the next round?’. It’s a tricky one to answer. There have been instances of providers being selected in the random sample two or even three years in a row. The ESFA’s view is that providers should always be ‘audit ready’, so plan that you’re going to be audited. Keep on top of your data, make sure that PDSATs are being run regularly and reviewed, that FRM’s are being downloaded and investigated, and all learner documentation is up to date.
Funding assurance reviews are generally delivered in time to coincide with the R14 submission date. Notifications are usually sent to selected providers in June/July.
Here’s a timetable of events from notification to fieldwork:
| Activity | Timing |
|---|---|
| Notification of review date | Agreed with auditor, usually agreed 5-10 working days after being notified |
| ILR provided to auditor | 2-3 weeks prior to agreed date of review |
| Notification of sample to provider | 5-10 working days prior to the agreed date of review |
| Sample collation | Completed in the 5-10 days prior to review commencing |
| Fieldwork | Completed in agreed week |
| Outstanding evidence from sample | |
| Up to 5 working days after the fieldwork was completed |
Other activities such as bursary and free meal audits may take place throughout the year and are generally completed by the ESFA directly.
Where providers are in receipt of MCA AEB funding, the MCA concerned can audit at any time of the year, and each MCA has their own assurance arrangements. MCA learners are not included in the ESFA review if the provider is in receipt of funding from both funders.
For an ESFA assurance reviews the following funding streams may be in scope: